City Know-hows
The study presents an evaluation of how mobile phone data can be used to evaluate place-based green space interventions. It uses a case study of wildflower planting in Liverpool.
Share
Target audience
Community organisations involved in planting wildflowers. Council officials involved in parks and nature-based solutions.
The problem
There is limited evaluation of whether green space interventions lead to more people using these spaces. This is partly due to the difficulty of collecting data on visits to green spaces. Mobile phone data may offer one solution, but are rarely made available to researchers. As such, there is less examination of whether these data are valuable. We accessed small area anonymised mobile phone GPS data for Liverpool (2021-2022). Using a case study of wildflower planting, we identified green spaces where wildflowers were planted. A synthetic control was then constructed to identify similar green spaces where planting did not take place. We then compared the number of visits post-intervention between the intervention and control green sites.
What we did and why
We accessed small area anonymised mobile phone GPS data for Liverpool (2021-2022). Using a case study of wildflower planting, we identified green spaces where wildflowers were planted. A synthetic control was then constructed to identify similar green spaces where planting did not take place. We then compared the number of visits post-intervention between intervention and control green sites.
Our study’s contribution
The planting of wildflowers led to 17.2% higher number of visits than expected in the first month of the intervention, declining thereafter. There was wide uncertainty in these estimates, and we could not ascertain statistical significance. Our paper also gives an empirical and methodological evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of using mobile phone data, which can inform others on how to best use them.
Impacts for city policy and practice
Where policy organisations use mobile phone-derived datasets, they should report openly on how their data is affected by the limitations and biases we report. Organisations should openly evaluate the effectiveness of all green space interventions so we can learn what works for encouraging greater use of green space. Where possible, evaluations should use both mobile phone data and manual visitation counts to minimise methodological differences in findings.
Further information
Full research article:
How can mobility data be used to evaluate urban green space interventions? A synthetic control analysis of wildflower planting in Liverpool, UK (2021–2022) by Mark A. Green, Wenjing Zhang, Polly Moseley, Richard Scott, Olly Butters, Ruoyo Wang, Benedict W. Wheeler & Rebecca S. Geary
Related posts
I diagnose urbanization’s toll: 60% of city dwellers face stress-related morbidity, which biophilic design aims to curb; yet my 100-study review reveals biophobia’s backlash, like glare spiking cortisol 10%. This dialectic, rooted in evolutionary and urban disconnect, exacerbates health inequities e.g., 30% higher stress in underserved areas —demanding my evidence-based, Hegelian synthesis to recalibrate architecture for resilience.
We reviewed the existing research on influencing rewilding behaviour by city residents in their gardens. We used a behaviour-change model to identify intervention and policy strategies that affect residents’ rewilding behaviour. We found that all intervention and policy categories were effective, requiring action across many organisations and areas to drive change.
This study measured the effectiveness of stepping stones as an element of landscape design – to make walking a more effective form of exercise for health. The average increase in heart rate due to steppingstones was 17.22%. In conclusion, we estimate that stepping stones can significantly increase peoples metabolic and physiological parameters, and can help the wider population to achieve the recommended government and health guidelines of ‘moderate exercise’ of 150 min/week, improving population health. This new evidence can help designers to implement ‘Active Urbanism’ strategies.
