City Know-hows

Understanding playgrounds for inclusive and dynamic urban experiences

Children painting in the square in San Giacomo dell Orio. Credit: J.A. Lara-Hernandez (Mews, Lara-Hernandez and Sbarra, 2024).

This study explores how urban playground design can either segregate or integrate children within the broader city fabric. By comparing Venice and Auckland, we illustrate how playgrounds in Venice encourage unstructured exploration, while those in Auckland limit engagement to isolated, structured zones. We propose strategies for urban design that foster inclusive and dynamic public spaces for children.

Share

Target audience

Architects, urban planners, and designers; Policymakers and decision-makers; Advocacy groups for child-friendly cities

The problem

Urban playgrounds are often designed to overemphasise safety, inadvertently creating spatial segregation. This limits children’s opportunities for exploration, temporary appropriation of spaces, and engagement with the socio-cultural dynamics of the city.

What we did and why

In our research, we compared playgrounds and public spaces in two distinct urban contexts,Venice and Auckland, to understand how design affects children’s interactions with their environments. Using the concept of temporary appropriation, the study highlights the importance of unstructured spaces in fostering children’s social and cognitive development.

Our study’s contribution

The findings advocate for hybrid playground designs that balance safety with exploration.

  • In Venice, integrated public spaces enable diverse and spontaneous interactions, promoting inclusivity and resilience.
  • In Auckland, fenced and structured playgrounds isolate children from the dynamic urban realm, reducing engagement opportunities.

Impacts for city policy and practice

Based on our study, we recommend that cities need to:

  • Create hybrid playgrounds that integrate structured and unstructured elements within urban environments.
  • Incorporate inclusive design principles to ensure access for children across diverse socio-economic contexts.
  • Use participatory planning processes to involve children in the design of public spaces that reflect their needs and aspirations.

Further information

Full research article:

Related posts

City design must respect young people’s rights and consider their lived experiences. Meaningful participation is a powerful protective factor!

Violence and abuse by and among youth are critical public health issues. Building equitable cities requires centring the voices of marginalised young people, whose experiences provide vital insights into safer urban spaces. Supporting marginalised youth in shaping safer cities is a delicate balance, like the porcupine’s dilemma; —nurturing participation while ensuring protection. Together, we can create safer, more equitable spaces for all.

Read More »

The impact of apartment design on changes in housing satisfaction during the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown

Our study investigated whether apartment dwelling and building design attributes influenced residents’ housing satisfaction in the initial stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. Multivariate models showed that residents’ perceptions of their apartment’s internal space and layout and the thermal comfort it afforded them in winter were independently associated with increased housing satisfaction.

Read More »